Toronto
Don Martin hosts Power Play on CTV News Channel, highlighting the people and players that dominate the political scene in Canada.


Don Martin's BioAbout Power Play

Don Martin on TwitterDon Martin on Twitter

Power Play on TwitterPower Play on Twitter

CTV Power Play on FacebookCTV Power Play on Facebook



FeedSubscribe


Share |


Ralph Klein should receive Order of Canada before it's too late

6. January 2012 19:44  by Don Martin

Ralph Klein passes his days in a long-term care facility in Calgary surrounded by comfortable reminders of his colourful life.

The 69-year-old spends a lot of time in bed, barely speaking while struggling to penetrate the fog of dementia, which has displaced the sharpest political mind in the business. Ailing physically as well, he is not expected to ever return to his modest bungalow in southwest Calgary.

He deserves a better fate in life. And before his death, he should receive the national honour, which remains denied to this most worthy of candidates.

Twice a year they post the Order of Canada recipients. I always scan the list of first-class Canadians expecting to see the former broadcaster, Calgary mayor and Alberta premier prominently featured atop the news release.

The most recent batch came out last week. Another 66 names - and not one of them was Ralph Klein.

How can this be? Former premiers are regularly on the list. When I complained about the glaring oversight, one journalist quipped: "Would he know if he got it anyway?"

Probably not. But that's beside the point. It's been five years since Klein retired after a generation in multi-tiered politics topped by a four-term run as premier during a particularly difficult time.

Former Alberta premier Peter Lougheed and former Ontario premier Bill Davis barely waited a year after retiring to be pinned with their OC. Saskatchewan's Roy Romanow got his within two years. Other premiers such as Gordon Campbell and Gary Doer received juicy diplomatic appointments upon their retirement.

Yet the populist phenomenon known by everyone as simply ‘Ralph' hasn't rated a sideways glance from Ottawa, even though a fellow Calgarian is the prime minister and a fellow Albertan is the chief justice who supervises the nomination process.

This reeks of a snobby Ottawa establishment deciding a hard-living high school dropout with a cigarette-mooching habit and fondness for red wine isn't worth the lapel pin that passes for the Order of Canada status symbol. In other words, mere mortals need not apply. He is not of their class.

What's overlooked is a track record of hosting a magnificent 1988 Winter Olympics as Calgary mayor and rescuing Alberta from massive deficit in the early 1990s as a rookie premier. Former prime minister Jean Chretien once told me Klein gave him the inspiration to balance the federal books, knowing it could be done without a catastrophic loss of public support.

"He gave 26 years of his life to public service. If that doesn't qualify him, what does?" wonders Klein's close friend and former chief of staff Rod Love.

What indeed.

I'll refrain from quibbling whether 2012 recipients such as former hockey coach Scotty Bowman, sportscaster Brian Williams or former top bureaucrat Kevin Lynch deserve the Order of Canada, but are any of them in the same public service league as Ralph Klein?

The answer's a big, fat, rhetorical NO.

There's a potential way to challenge the upper-crust objections to giving the honor to average-guy phenomenon.

After I tweeted my disgust at the latest Klein omission, several Calgary heavyweights confided they would be lobbying the Governor General to right this wrong. The public can get involved too. There's a nomination form on the Governor General's website. If you think he's worthy, send in a recommendation. If there's enough public pressure, David Johnston just might add Klein's name to the list coming out in late June.

Even if he might not grasp the significance of getting it as the cerebral clouds thicken and his body fails, Ralph Klein deserves the recognition of joining the Order of Canada now -- before it's too late.

Tags:

Comments (16) -

1/6/2012 8:19:08 PM #

While I never agreed with Mr. Klein from a policy perspective, you have to give credit for someone who continued to mobilize one party as a stronghold. I'm gay. I'm for lack of a better term "a socialist" or a "liberal" - and I still admire this man for the years and dedication he put in to serving his province, despite my disagreements with his social policies.

The circumstances of ones personal life, like Mr. Klein, shouldn't matter. He, unlike a few who have stripped the order away, did not make extremely disparaging remarks; wasn't involved in child sexual abuse, murder or anything considered extreme. Despite the opposition to Mr. Morgantaler receiving the award (an achievement I supported), he was still recognized for his work for womens sexual and reproductive health. Isn't that what the Order of Canada is about - standing up for people and dedicating your life to a group of individuals, whether it be women, ethnic or immigrant communities, sexual minorities, politics, your country, religion or those from lower socio-economic statuses? Who cares if some people opposed your social or other political policies; it's the investment of your life to standing up for a cause you believe in that matters.

Mark Hanlon |

1/6/2012 8:30:39 PM #

Love him or hate him he gave 26 years of his life to public service and did what he thought was right for Alberta and Albertans.  He deserves this honour

Brian |

1/6/2012 9:32:09 PM #

No order of Canada for Klein and it should stay that way. He's the one that made possible for all these mega oil companies to come and rape our beautiful landscape in the name of $$$. Let's not give the order to a nature wrecker like him.

Sylvain Lortie |

1/6/2012 9:48:23 PM #

Good comments! I second your nomination of Ralph. He served this nation well and with honour, it is sad we are not returning the favour!

James |

1/6/2012 11:23:59 PM #

"He gave 26 years of his life to public service. If that doesn't qualify him, what does?"

By that reasoning, every civil service lifer and government cheque collector should get automatically nominated and saluted after they've done their time.

You hit the nail on the head though Don - what if the OC has become a meaningless, politicized and arbitrary exercise in self-love, denied to those outside the clique?

Does that mean it's going away soon?

captcold |

1/7/2012 12:35:32 AM #

I couldn't agree more. He has done what most premiers couldn't do: put his province on a successful footing. As far as I'm concerned he accomplished more than Layton who received a state funeral.

Frib |

1/7/2012 1:33:12 AM #

This is @webwildink from Twitter.

I want you to know that the Northern Gateway Pipeline Project has a major flaw.  The Tankers that will transport oil to China are taking the wrong route through the "Inside Passage."  It is far too narrow for tankers to
navigate, especially when cruise ships and ferries travel the same route.  I know this because I spent my live navigating those waters.  The pipeline should exit at Prince Rupert, in order to avoid the inside passage.
Most people are not aware of this danger, and simply accept that Kitimat BC should be the port of choice.  This is a grave error on the part of oil companies.  The "Inside Passage is much more narrow and dangerous than the Exon Valdez  waterway tragedy.

@webwildink.

@webwildink |

1/7/2012 3:00:53 AM #

Dear Don:

Your comment on today's show suggesting that former Alberta Premier Ralph Klien be presented the Order of Canada was a welcomed gesture to my ears.  Your comments were sincere and correct.  I have a renewed respect for journalists.  Well done Don.

David Gallant |

1/7/2012 3:05:52 AM #

I totally agree with you Don.  As a resident of British Columbia I always wished that " King Ralph" was our premier.  He did a lot for his people/province and well, who didn't like Ralph ( with the possible exception of the Ottawa elites as you note).  I am adding your commentary to my Facebook to help to spread the word........King Ralph deserves the Order of Canada.

Kathy |

1/7/2012 4:33:29 AM #

I don't see how someone dying qualifies them for the Order of Canada. Klein's public service record, while arguably in the name of, and for the people of, Alberta, was most often contrary to the needs and benefits of Canadians and Canada as a whole. Further, he was never more than a regional figure. Quite frankly, you can't argue that Klein belongs without also arguing that Jacques Parizeau does. Does Klein deserve to be in the Order of Alberta? Yes. The Order of Canada? No.

Warren |

1/7/2012 5:08:28 AM #

From the point of view of some Albertans, former Premier Ralph Klein was indeed a great leader, a colourful personality and a strong advocate for the rights of that province within the Dominion. However, assinine comments like "let those eastern bastards freeze in the dark" and his statement that eastern Canada was sending all their criminals and ne'er-do-wells to Alberta and most crimes committed in Alberta could be traced to them, did little to endear him to the rest of Canada. The Order of Canada is meant to honour those who, during their lives, have demonstrated qualities that make our country great. Ralph Klein is certainly not among those who reflect our shared values or any of the traits that make Canada and Canadians unique, in my opinion.

Kenn Wright |

1/7/2012 6:02:24 AM #

Not only did Gordon Campbell receive a "juicy" diplomatic appointment upon  retirement, he received this appointment in spite of drunk driving charges that he incurred in Hawaii in 2003. He entered a no-contest plea to these charges.

This certainly indicates a double standard when compared to today's news about Mr. Goldring.

Marcia |

1/7/2012 7:18:16 AM #

Klein - receive the Order of Canada.  Only in my nightmares.

Ann |

1/7/2012 9:27:34 AM #

They hand the OoC out to so many people each year that it's value is questionable. And with Klein there's still a lot of animosity among Alberta's media elites, cultural elites, unions &bureaucrats towards him.

Ian berg |

1/7/2012 10:34:53 PM #

How can this be asks Mr. Martin.Well some Canadians don't care for Mr.Klein referring to Eastern Canadians as Bastards and wishing them to freeze in the dark.Also Mr.Klein's preference to visit a casino rather than participate in a meeting of all premiers hardly displayed a sincere interest in the betterment of Canada.His comments on the Mad Cow problem were less than helpful.
I regret the health problems Mr. Klein is confronted with but did he really but all Canada first?
Hector Wright

Hector Wright |

1/8/2012 6:07:21 AM #

Enjoy the program most every day, you really got my attention with your story of Ralph Klein being overlooked for the "Order of Canada".
It is quite distressing to imagine how this great Albertan and Canadian could be passed over, I would have thought he would have been an automatic nominee.
Thanks for bringing this story to the forefront.

Robert Black |

Pingbacks and trackbacks (3)+

Comments are closed